The BEST Sauces for Breakfast Sandwiches!

From classics like ketchup and mayonnaise to more adventurous options, there are a myriad of sauces out there to perfectly complement your morning meal.

In this article, we’ll explore some of the best sauce options to enhance your breakfast sandwich experience!

Without any further ado, let’s get going with the best sauces for breakfast sandwiches…

Classic Sauces for Breakfast Sandwiches

Buttery Delicacies

A classic sauce for your breakfast sandwich is, of course, butter.

It enhances the flavour of your bacon and melted cheese, adding a delicious richness.

You can spread a generous layer of softened butter on your English muffin.

Another delightful buttery option is garlic butter.

To make it at home, simply combine softened butter, crushed garlic, and a pinch of salt.

This versatile sauce is excellent for early mornings when savoury cravings kick in. It complements bacon, cheese, and other ingredients splendidly, amping up your sandwich’s taste.

Mustardy Marvels

Two mustard-based sauces that work wonders on breakfast sandwiches are classic mustard and honey mustard.

The tangy flavour of mustard pairs nicely with breakfast sandwich staples, such as bacon, cheese, and eggs.

Classic Mustard: A good-quality English mustard or Dijon mustard will do the trick. Spread a thin layer on your English muffin to ensure you don’t overpower the other ingredients. The sharp, zesty flavour of classic mustard contributes a welcome kick to your breakfast sandwich.
Honey Mustard: For a slightly sweeter option, honey mustard combines the tanginess of mustard with the natural sweetness of honey. You can easily make homemade honey mustard by mixing equal parts mustard and honey, or feel free to use a store-bought version. A dollop of this sauce complements the smoky flavour of bacon and the creaminess of melted cheese very well.

Don’t forget about the ever-popular mayo and ketchup.

These classic sauces can also bring your breakfast sandwich to new heights.

A simple mayo, whether homemade or store-bought, adds a smooth, creamy texture that plays well with other ingredients. Ketchup, on the other hand, adds a sweet and tangy contrast to the savoury flavours of bacon and cheese.

Spicy and Tangy Twists

When it comes to breakfast sandwiches, a good sauce can take your meal to the next level.

For those who love a bit of heat, spicy and tangy twists are a popular choice…

Saucy Sriracha Selections

If you’re keen on adding a spicy kick to your breakfast sandwiches, sriracha is your best friend. This vibrant red sauce, originally from Thailand, packs a perfect blend of heat, sweetness, and tanginess. Here are some simple ways to incorporate sriracha into your morning:

Sriracha Mayo: Combine equal parts mayonnaise and sriracha for a creamy, spicy spread.
Sriracha Ketchup: Mix two parts ketchup with one part sriracha for a tangy and fiery sauce.
Sriracha and Garlic: Stir in minced garlic and a few dashes of sriracha to your sandwich spread for an added layer of flavour.

These sriracha options are versatile and can complement most breakfast sandwich fillings such as bacon, eggs, or avocado.

Hot Sauce Heroes

To satisfy your craving for spiciness, you might want to explore other hot sauce options aside from sriracha.

Here are some top choices for your next breakfast sandwich adventure:

Classic Tabasco: This tried-and-true hot sauce is made from vinegar, salt, and tabasco peppers. Its tangy heat complements classic egg sandwiches or breakfast burritos.
Cholula: With a blend of tomato, garlic, and various spices, Cholula offers a milder heat and distinct flavour profile. Drizzle over your favourite veggie-stuffed sandwich for a tangy twist.
Sambal Oelek: Hailing from Indonesia, this chilli paste delivers heat with a touch of tanginess. Mix a small amount into a creamy spread to balance out the heat, or dab it on your sandwich toppings for a burst of flavour.

Remember to adjust the amount of hot sauce according to your personal heat tolerance, and experiment with different combinations to find your perfect spicy and tangy breakfast sandwich sauce.

Healthy and Tasty Options

Avocado-Based Alternatives

Let’s start with avocado, a versatile and nutritious ingredient that can transform your breakfast sandwiches.

Mashed avocado can be cleverly combined with other flavours to create a delicious spread for your sandwich.

Rich in healthy fats, fibre, and vitamins, it’ll give your morning a nutritious boost.

For a simple avocado spread, mash avocado with a squeeze of lemon juice and a pinch of salt and pepper.

You will not only add creaminess to your sandwich but also a delightful tanginess.

You can also experiment with other ingredients like basil, lime juice, or diced tomatoes to keep your breakfast interesting. Homemade guacamole is a delicious addition to any meal!

Hummus and Pesto Possibilities

Hummus is another fantastic option for a healthy breakfast sandwich sauce.

Made from chickpeas, olive oil, lemon juice, and garlic, it provides a tasty and protein-packed alternative to traditional spreads.

With a wide range of flavours available, you can easily incorporate hummus to suit your breakfast preferences.

Flavour	Accompanying Ingredients
Classic Hummus	Cucumber, tomatoes, lettuce, or sprouts
Spicy Hummus	Roasted red pepper, grilled halloumi, or eggs
Beetroot Hummus	Avocado, watercress, or feta cheese

Pesto is a delicious herb-based sauce that can amp up the flavour of your breakfast sandwiches.

Made primarily from basil, olive oil, and pine nuts, it offers an excellent medley of zest and creaminess.

Don’t feel limited by traditional pesto – try experimenting with other herbs, nuts, or seeds to find your favourite version.

Herb Variations: Rocket, coriander, or parsley
Nut Variations: Walnuts, cashews, or almonds

Using a ready made version? Take a look at how to improve store bought pesto!

Delightfully Sweet Sauces

Honey and Jam Jumbles

Treat yourself to a delightful burst of sweetness on your breakfast sandwiches with these honey and jam jumbles.

A simple blend of honey, jam, and lemon juice will brighten up your morning meal.

Start by choosing your favourite jam – it could be strawberry, raspberry, or even apricot. Then, in a small bowl, mix equal parts jam and honey.

Add a squeeze of lemon juice to cut through the sweetness and enhance the flavours.

Spread a generous dollop of this mixture onto your sandwich for a deliciously sweet start to the day.

Aside from the classic fruit jams, consider experimenting with other flavours like fig or marmalade. Here are some combinations to try:

Strawberry jam + honey + lemon juice
Raspberry jam + honey + a pinch of cinnamon
Orange marmalade + honey + a splash of apple cider vinegar

Syrup Surprises

Another sweet option for your breakfast sandwich is syrup surprises.

Drizzle a rich and sticky syrup onto your sandwich for a sumptuous addition that will surely satisfy your sweet tooth.

Opt for maple syrup for a classic choice or go for more inventive options like golden syrup or fruit-based syrups. Just be mindful of the level of sweetness, as too much syrup can overpower other flavours in your sandwich.

A sweet syrup can elevate your sandwich to new heights when paired expertly with other ingredients, like:

Bacon + golden syrup
Sausage + maple syrup
Banana + berry syrup

Remember, a little drizzle goes a long way, so don’t overdo it!

Creamy and Rich Creations

Breakfast sandwiches are a delightful way to start your day, and choosing the perfect sauce can elevate them to a whole new level of deliciousness.

In this section, we will explore some creamy and rich sauce options, focusing on hollandaise and chipotle mayo mixtures.

These sauces will add depth and flavour to your favourite breakfast creations, including bagels and avocado toast.

Hollandaise Highlights

Hollandaise sauce is a classic choice for adding richness to your breakfast sandwich.

Made from a blend of egg yolks, butter, lemon juice, and a slight hint of cayenne pepper, this velvety sauce provides a luxurious mouthfeel and a smooth, creamy texture.

To make your own hollandaise sauce, follow these simple steps:

Whisk egg yolks, lemon juice, and a pinch of cayenne pepper together in a heatproof bowl.
Place the bowl over a saucepan of barely simmering water, ensuring the water doesn’t touch the bottom of the bowl.
Gradually add melted, warm butter, whisking constantly until the sauce is thickened and smooth.

Once your sauce is ready, feel free to pair it with an array of breakfast ingredients on your sandwich, such as:

Smoked salmon
Poached eggs
Sautéed mushrooms

Chipotle Mayo Mixtures

For those who crave a kick of spice, chipotle mayo is a fantastic option.

This zesty condiment consists of mayonnaise mixed with chipotle peppers in adobo sauce, providing a smoky and spicy flavour.

You can easily create your own chipotle mayo by simply combining the following ingredients:

Mayonnaise
Chipotle peppers in adobo sauce (finely chopped)
Lime juice

After mixing, your chipotle mayo is ready to enhance your breakfast sandwich. Here are some scrumptious ingredient combinations to consider:

Bacon, egg, and avocado
Grilled halloumi and roasted red peppers
Turkey, spinach, and tomato

Considerations for Different Bread Types

Bagel and Croissant Combinations

When it comes to breakfast sandwiches, the type of bread you use can make or break the entire dish. For bagels and croissants, it’s essential to choose a sauce that complements their unique textures.

A creamy sauce works well with these bread types, as it adds a delightful contrast.

Consider arugula and parmesan sauce for a savoury twist on your morning meal. The peppery arugula and tangy parmesan enhance the flavour, while also providing an extra layer of nutrition.

Another great option for both bagels and croissants are mushroom-based sauces.

Mushrooms add a rich, earthy taste, and when combined with a creamy sauce, they create a luxurious topping perfect for upgrading your breakfast sandwich.

Bread Type	Sauce
Bagel	Arugula and Parmesan Sauce
Croissant	Creamy Mushroom Sauce

Biscuit and English Muffin Mixes

Biscuits and English muffins are popular choices for breakfast sandwiches, thanks to their versatility and satisfying texture.

When working with these types of bread, opt for sauces that are high in protein, as this will not only elevate the flavour profile but also provide a satisfying and filling breakfast option.

One ideal sauce for biscuits and English muffins is a herb and cheese sauce.

This type of sauce incorporates a blend of herbs and cheese which not only adds a depth of flavour but also provides a protein boost to your morning meal.

For a lighter option, try a fresh tomato and avocado salsa on your biscuits or English muffin sandwich. It’s a delicious, nutritious, and easy-to-make sauce that can quickly be whipped up for a hassle-free breakfast.

Bread Type	Sauce
Biscuit	Herb and Cheese Sauce
English Muffin	Fresh Tomato and Avocado Salsa

Conclusion

In the end, the key to a perfect breakfast sandwich is choosing the right sauce to complement your ingredients.

The following options make great choices:

Hollandaise sauce: A classic choice, perfect for pairing with eggs Benedict or smoked salmon.
Pesto: A fresh and vibrant addition to a veggie-packed sandwich, with basil, garlic, and pine nuts.
Tomato chutney: A delicious, tangy sauce that adds a touch of sweetness to balance out salty bacon or sausage.
Sriracha mayo: For those who like a little heat in their morning meal, this spicy yet creamy sauce is ideal.

Remember to be creative and feel free to mix and match sauces with different fillings. Trust your taste buds and personal preferences when selecting the right sauce for your breakfast sandwich!

Before you go, you might also want to take a look at the best sauces for steak sandwiches.