How To Improve Store Bought Pizza Sauce: BEST Tips!

We’ve all been there – you’ve got a store-bought pizza sauce in your pantry, and while it’s a convenient option, it doesn’t quite deliver that pizzazz you’re craving.

Fear not, pizza enthusiasts!

Even the most basic sauce can be enhanced to deliver a restaurant-quality experience at home.

Allow us to serve up some scrumptious tips on how to improve store-bought pizza sauce. With a few simple tweaks, your homemade pizzas will have your guests thinking you’ve hired a professional chef! 

Let’s get going… 

Assessing Store-Bought Pizza Sauce

Choosing the perfect store-bought pizza sauce can be quite the challenge, with so many brands and variations available in the market. However, worry not, as you’re about to discover some key factors to consider when picking the right sauce for your homemade pizza endeavours!

Firstly, it is essential to give importance to the ingredients that make up your chosen sauce.

Opt for a sauce with a shorter ingredient list, consisting of a tomato base, spices, oil, and a preservative. This will ensure that you’re bringing home a more natural and delicious sauce to enhance your pizza’s flavours.

When assessing your store-bought pizza sauce, it’s a good idea to examine the balance of flavours. Look for a sauce with a nice blend of tangy tomatoes, a hint of savouriness, and a subtle touch of herbs. If necessary, refer to taste tests to gauge which sauces are deemed the best by emboldened taste buds.

Now, texture does play a vital role in a good pizza sauce. No one fancies a watery or overly thick sauce that fails to complement their pizza. The ideal store-bought pizza sauce should have a smooth and medium consistency that generously coats your pizza base without turning it soggy.

Lastly, do remember to have a bit of fun in the process by experimenting with different brands until you find the one that makes your pizza night truly delightful. 

Customising Flavour Profiles

When it comes to how to improve store bought pizza sauce, one of the best options is the addition of fresh ingredients and herbs and spices… 

Adding Fresh Ingredients

Sometimes, it’s the simplest additions that make a significant impact on flavour. Toss in freshly chopped garlic, onions, or bell peppers for an instant flavour boost. You might also consider sautéing mushrooms and tossing them into the sauce.

For those who fancy a touch of sweetness, try adding fresh cherry tomatoes or caramelised onions to balance and elevate the taste.

For a bit of decadence, consider using red wine to improve the sauce.

Wine not only adds depth of flavour but also accompanies well with other ingredients like onions, garlic, and herbs. Give it a swig!

Using Herbs and Spices

A sprig here, a dash there — herbs and spices can make a world of difference in the overall taste of your store-bought pizza sauce. For a touch of earthiness, add some fresh basil leaves or dried oregano.

Be careful not to add too much oregano, though — too much can result in a bitter taste and even heartburn, as PMQ Pizza Magazine cautions.

A little heat might be just what your sauce needs! Experiment with red pepper flakes or freshly ground black pepper to add some kick. For a deeper, more aromatic flavour profile, consider adding spices like fennel seeds or smoked paprika.

Remember, when it comes to customising the flavour of your pizza sauce, the possibilities are as vast as the toppings one can add to their pizza. Have fun and let your inner chef run wild!

Adjusting Sauce Consistency

Having the perfect consistency for your pizza sauce is key to creating a memorable pizza experience. Too thick or too thin, and the sauce won’t spread evenly on the dough or mingle properly with the toppings. But have no fear, dear pizza makers!

In this section, we’ll explore a few techniques to adjust the consistency of your store-bought pizza sauce.

First and foremost, if your sauce is too thick, you can easily thin it down by adding a small amount of water, vegetable stock, or even red wine. Start with a small amount and mix well, then assess the consistency and adjust accordingly. Remember, it’s easier to add liquid than to remove it!

Now, let’s say your sauce is too thin. One method to tackle this issue is to cook the sauce down by simmering it gently, over low heat, until the desired thickness is achieved. Slow cooking will not only thicken your sauce, but also impart a better flavour. Just be mindful to stir occasionally to prevent sticking and scorching.

Another way to thicken a thin sauce is to add starchy ingredients. For example, you can incorporate a small amount of cornstarch or arrowroot, mixed first with cold water to create a slurry. Stir the slurry into your sauce, and the resulting mixture will thicken as it cooks.

According to Countertop Pizza Oven, it’s essential to store such thickened sauces in airtight containers to maintain consistency.

With these tips in hand, you’re now equipped to create a perfectly consistent store-bought pizza sauce that will have your guests thinking you’ve spent hours in the kitchen. 

Incorporating Other Sauces

When it comes to how to improve store bought pizza sauce, you shouldn’t overlook the potential of incorporating other sauces.

By doing so, you can create a delightful mixture that elevates the overall flavour of your pizza. Let’s have a look at some wonderful sauce additions and how to combine them with the store-bought sauce:

Pesto: Pesto, with its rich blend of basil, garlic, pine nuts, and cheese, can bring a distinct depth to your pizza sauce. Simply mix a spoonful of pesto into the sauce and taste the magic it creates. Taste as you go, so the pesto doesn’t overpower the tomato base.

Barbecue sauce: For a smoky and sweet twist, consider adding a few dashes of your favourite barbecue sauce. This flavourful addition works particularly well with meat toppings such as pulled pork or grilled chicken. Just remember to add sparingly, as overpowering the tomato base is not the end goal.

Hot sauce: Spice lovers shouldn’t shy away from this option. A few drops of hot sauce can inject a pleasant heat into the pizza sauce without completely dominating the natural tomato flavour. Consider experimenting with different types of hot sauces, such as Sriracha or Tabasco, to find the perfect balance.

Garlic and herb sauce: If looking to focus on the savoury profile, adding a garlic and herb sauce can work wonders. Mixing this sauce with the store-bought pizza sauce creates a harmonious blend that highlights the classic garlic flavour, enhancing the taste of any pizza.

To create a successful marriage between the store-bought pizza sauce and these additional sauces, take care to mix them in gradually.

Gauge the taste and texture of the blend, ensuring neither sauce dominates the other. Remember, the key is to complement the original sauce, not overshadow it. 

Cooking Techniques for Enhanced Flavours

As any adventurous cook knows, there is always room for improvement when it comes to store-bought ingredients.

As luck would have it, enhancing store-bought pizza sauce can be as easy as learning a few new cooking techniques.

First, let’s heat things up a bit. A little warmth goes a long way in releasing the robust flavours hidden in pre-made sauce.

Gently simmering the sauce in a saucepan allows the flavours to meld together and creates a richer taste. Remember, however, not to boil it, as it may result in a loss of texture and flavour intensity. Aim for a gentle simmer, and make sure you’re stirring occasionally to prevent sticking.

For those who want to pull out all the stops, adding a splash of red wine can transform any store-bought sauce into a heavenly concoction. Cooking off the alcohol leaves the subtleties of the wine to be absorbed by the sauce, enriching its flavour and taking it to new gastronomic heights. 

Lastly, putting a bit of thought into the cooking container can have a significant impact. Selecting a heavy-bottomed saucepan helps heat to distribute more evenly, ensuring your sauce does not scorch or burn. The use of non-stick cookware can also be beneficial, saving you from a sticky situation and a potential flavour disaster.

By mastering these cooking techniques, you’ll be well on your way to elevating even the most basic store-bought sauce into a piece of pizza perfection.

Storing Modified Pizza Sauce

After applying the delightful tips and tricks to enhance the store-bought pizza sauce, storing the perfected concoction becomes essential to preserve its flavour profile.

This section will reveal the secrets of how to keep your modified sauce fresher for longer, adding a cheeky zing to your future pizza masterpieces.

When it comes to refrigeration, it’s quite a simple task. All that’s required is a posh mason jar or any airtight storage container, really. Just pour your sauce in, cover tightly, and let it rest in the chilly recesses of your fridge for a good one to two weeks (NatashasKitchen.com). With any luck, each time you open the fridge, the anticipation of that next delicious pizza shall beckon.

For those who fancy the thrill of planning their pizza sauce adventures well in advance, freezing is another splendid option. Just follow these straightforward steps:

  • Portion the sauce into freezer-safe zip bags,
  • Remove any extra air and seal,
  • Lay the bags flat in the freezer, ensuring they’re adequately spaced apart,
  • Wait patiently for the sauce to freeze solid,
  • Marvel at your exemplary planning skills and enjoy the convenience of ready-to-use, flavourful sauce for up to six months 

Remember, proper storage is the key to ensuring your store-bought pizza sauce, now expertly improved by your culinary skills, remains a delightful addition to your pizzas for weeks or months to come. So, store it right and relish the scrumptious results!

If you’re interested in how to improve store bought pizza sauce, you might also be interested in some of our other guides to making the most of pantry staples, including potato salad, coleslaw, and curry sauce