Toasties Without Cheese: 7 Cheese-Free Recipes To Try!

You can’t beat a good toastie! It’s a quick and easy lunch or satisfying snack that’s often a welcome change from your usual sandwich, and the only limit to the fillings you can enjoy is your own creativity and imagination. 

But if you’re avoiding cheese, either because of an allergy or intolerance, or simply because you want to explore some other culinary choices for your toasted sandwiches, you might be a little stumped for ideas. 

The good news is that there are plenty of delicious choices for toasties without cheese! 

The best toasties without cheese

In a rush and just want to grab a few ideas then get down to making your toastie? No worries!

The best ideas for toasties without cheese include full English breakfast toastie; bacon, tomato, and avocado toastie; sardine toastie; chilli con carne toastie; ham, tomato, and pesto toastie; baked bean toastie; and banana and peanut butter toastie. 

Keep reading for instructions and recipes for making your perfect toasted sarnie. 

1. Full English breakfast toastie 

Everyone loves a full English breakfast, right? So for something a little bit different, try incorporating all your favourite elements into a toasted sandwich! 

You can add bacon, sausage, baked beans, mushrooms, fresh tomatoes, pretty much any ingredient that you’d typically find on your breakfast plate. 

A good rule of thumb here is that you should cook all the components before you make your sandwich, so you only really need to worry about toasting the bread, and then you’re good to go. 

2. Bacon, tomato, and avocado toastie 

Salty bacon, fresh and juicy tomatoes, and creamy avocado… This toastie without cheese is perfect for breakfast, or at any time of the day! 

Cook your bacon beforehand, slice your tomatoes thinly, and try to find an avocado that’s just ripe for the very best results. 

I like to serve this one with a side serving of crisps, and it’s the ideal option if you have friends over for brunch and want to offer something that’s easy but also a little bit sophisticated. 

3. Sardine toastie 

Sardines on toast is a nutritious and easy breakfast, and it’s very easy to turn this classic meal into a toastie. 

I like to use tinned sardines in tomato, as it adds a delicious sauciness to the sandwich and ensures that it isn’t dry. If you prefer, you could use sardines in olive oil, or add slices of seasoned fresh tomato. 

Best of all, sardines really are an underrated superfood. They’re rich in omega 3s, vitamin D, and a fantastic source of calcium, as well as being delicious. 

4. Chilli con carne toastie 

If you’re making a big batch of chilli con carne, use the leftovers to make a toasted sandwich. Though you can add cheese if you’d like to, it’s totally delicious without. The flavours in chilli con carne will often improve overnight, so you’ll be rewarded with a super tasty lunchtime treat. 

Stick with the Mexican vibe by serving with a side of nachos and some guacamole, salsa, or soured cream. 

Some extra filling ideas for toasties using leftovers include: 

• Bolognese sauce 
• Roast beef and mustard 
• Turkey and cranberry sauce 
• Gammon and pineapple salsa 

The bottom line is that if you have dinner leftovers in your fridge and you’re not sure what to do with them, putting them in a toastie is almost always a good idea! 

5. Ham, tomato, and pesto toastie 

Ham and tomato is a beautiful combination for an easy lunch, and its elevated when you add it to a toastie with a generous scraping of pesto. 

If you want to put in a bit of extra effort, why not try making your own pesto? It requires just 5 ingredients, and it’s a brilliant sauce to have in your fridge. 

It’ll keep for about a week when it’s refrigerated, and you can use it to stir through pasta or alongside chicken or salmon. Alternatively, you can pop it in the freezer in smaller portions, so you always have some at hand to enjoy. 

6. Baked bean toastie 

This is basically beans on toast, but a little more fun! Most of us always have a tin of baked beans in the pantry, so this is a great option for when your fridge is looking a little bare, but you want to make a lunch that the kids will love. 

You can take things up a notch by adding your favourite sauce. HP Brown Sauce and Frank’s Hot Sauce are my personal favourites, and a drop of Worcester really helps to add a deep savoury goodness to each bite.  

7. Banana and peanut butter toastie 

Who said that toastie fillings have to be savoury?! If you’ve got a bit of a sweet tooth, you’ll surely love a banana and peanut butter grilled sandwich! 

In fact, if you want toastie ideas without cheese, there are tons of sweet delights to consider, including: 

• Peanut butter and jam 
• Banana and chocolate spread 
• Stewed apple and cinnamon 
• Poached pears 

Toastie filling ideas with no cheese

If you’re swerving cheese, that doesn’t mean you can’t enjoy a delicious toastie! Some of the best toastie recipes with no cheese include:

• Full English breakfast toastie
• Bacon, tomato, and avocado toastie
• Sardine toastie
• Chilli con carne toastie
• Ham, tomato, and pesto toastie
• Baked bean toastie
• Banana and peanut butter toastie

If you try these toasties without cheese, do leave a comment below and share your thoughts.